if we build software that doesn't scale, that's okay because our communities are small, and it means the megas can't use it


I like this idea, but also have trouble reconciling it, on the upstream side, with needing scale for the things on which we build, and on the downstream side of needing scale to be accessible and inclusive.

maybe there are different kinds of scaling that help resolve this?

@deejoe I'm not sure how not scaling to, say, thousands of users reduces accessibility, except that it requires more instances to be set up?

there's a premise that some people hold that accessibility requires centralization, but i don't agree with that.

@tindall @deejoe accessibility requires the ability to offload some work from some people to other people setting up tools for those people

that can be centralization but it doesn't have to be

it can be

lateralization? :D i dunno :D

@brion @tindall

yeah, maybe that's an entirely different idea than what people usually mean by scale. I think being able to do needful things does mean "bigger" in absolute terms than many of us are comfortable with, but not necessarily the "move fast and break things on the way to acquiring market share and excluding competitors" type of scaling.

@deejoe @tindall ah, by scaling i specifically mean scaling to serve a larger number of people

obviously you can choose to do this 'poorly'

@brion @tindall

yeah, I don't know. Accessibility aside for the moment, we also see small communities struggle with shifting priorities over time, burnout in the people running things, chasing upgrades, moderating, a hothouse environment for personality clashes, all that.

Best way to put this that comes to me just now is to shoot for "organic scaling"?

Or to trot out a more familiar usage: How do we maintain critical mass without it either fizzle out or a blowing up?

@deejoe @brion I don't see that most things need a "critical mass", though, unless they want to capture a market through the network effect.


@tindall @deejoe @brion

Also as long as even a small community welcomes diversity, accessibility can be achieved.

I am part of a forum about vintage electronics where there are a lot of older people present, and the users will speak up if fonts / colours are hard to see and things get changed (they also share positive discussions on how to deal with doing things like close work and driving as their eyesight changes due to ageing)

Sign in to participate in the conversation

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!